---
title: Custom Agency Search | Find the Right Agency Partner | Setup
description: Find the right agency partner with Setup's Custom Agency Search. Get expert support with your brief, agency research, RFI/RFP process, and finalist selection.
image: https://info.setup.us/hubfs/SetupLogo_Tagline_FullColor-Apr-25-2025-04-35-42-4284-PM.png
---

[![Setup animated logo](https://info.setup.us/hubfs/logo/Setup-logo.gif "Setup animated logo")](https://setup.us/)

Open main menu Close main menu

[![Setup - marketing matchmakers](https://info.setup.us/hs-fs/hubfs/SetupLogo_Tagline_FullColor-Apr-25-2025-04-35-42-4284-PM.png?width=210&height=87&name=SetupLogo_Tagline_FullColor-Apr-25-2025-04-35-42-4284-PM.png "Setup - marketing matchmakers")](https://setup.us/)

**Custom Agency Search**

# Find the right agency partner for your brand.

**A custom search that's unique to your brand.**

Setup guides your team from defining the agency brief through research, RFI/RFP management, and finalist selection, helping you compare qualified agencies and make a confident decision.

Custom Agency Search is a paid service. We agree on scope, timing, and fees before work begins.

[Get Started with Custom Agency Search](https://share.hsforms.com/1PrIv865YQkCXArMBWmAa_Acpg62)

## When your agency search needs more support

Custom Agency Search brings structure to decisions involving complex requirements, multiple stakeholders, or a broader search beyond your existing agency options.

- **Start with a shared brief.** Align your team around the capabilities, experience, and working relationship you need.
- **Explore qualified agency options.** Research and evaluate agencies against your requirements.
- **Make a more informed decision.** Compare finalists consistently with guidance through evaluation and selection.

## How Our Custom Agency Search Works

**01**

### Discovery

We begin by understanding your business, key metrics, and stakeholder needs. Together, we develop an Agency Selection Brief and ideal agency profile to guide the search.

**02**

### Agency Research + Long List

We research and evaluate agencies against your brief, including outreach beyond Setup's existing network when needed, to develop a long list of qualified potential partners.

**03**

### Short List + Agency Selection

Through a structured RFI/RFP process, we further refine the list, providing you with a select group of top contenders to pitch. We guide you through finalist evaluations and selection.

## Deliverables That Drive Results

- **Agency Selection Brief:** An ideal agency profile that incorporates business and stakeholder needs.
- **Structured RFI and RFP:** Setup manages the process to narrow the universe of potential agencies.
- **Long Lists and Shortlists:** Qualified agencies who fit the brief.
- **Pitch Evaluation Scorecard:** Customized scorecards to evaluate pitches, guiding your team toward a consensus decision.

[Get Started with Custom Agency Search](https://share.hsforms.com/1PrIv865YQkCXArMBWmAa_Acpg62)

---

## Why Brands Trust Setup

**1,400+ brand-agency introductions**

Experience connecting brands and agencies across Setup's matchmaking work.

- **A search built around your needs.** Your brief guides agency research, evaluation, and recommendations.
- **A structured decision process.** RFIs, RFPs, and customized scorecards help your team compare qualified options.
- **Hands-on guidance.** Setup manages the search process and supports your team through finalist evaluation and selection.

> “Setup guided us through every step of finding the perfect agency, from stakeholder interviews to RFPs and final selection. Without their help, the process would have bogged down our team, delaying critical work. Highly recommend Setup for any brand seeking a Custom Agency Search.”  Ed Riegert III, Brooks Running

> “Setup acted as an extension of our team, guiding us through the Custom Agency Search process to find the perfect agency for our needs.”  Lisa Kummer, Great Clips

> “Setup’s Custom Agency Search saved me a huge amount of time vetting agencies while providing an unbiased perspective on potential partners.”  Barb Scherer, W.S. Badcock

> “Setup’s Custom Agency Search helped us narrow down to a handful of highly qualified marketing agencies, making it easy to choose ‘the one.’”  Dan McSwanson, Aaron’s

## Hear from our clients

<iframe src="https://player.vimeo.com/video/503572014?app_id=122963" width="640" height="360" title="Dan McSwanson on Setup Custom Agency Search" loading="lazy" allow="autoplay; fullscreen; picture-in-picture; encrypted-media" allowfullscreen referrerpolicy="strict-origin-when-cross-origin"></iframe>

### Dan McSwanson

Director of Marketing, Aaron’s

How Setup narrowed the search to a handful of highly qualified agencies and helped Aaron’s choose the right partner.

<iframe src="https://player.vimeo.com/video/516844767?app_id=122963" width="640" height="360" title="Barb Scherer on Setup Custom Agency Search" loading="lazy" allow="autoplay; fullscreen; picture-in-picture; encrypted-media" allowfullscreen referrerpolicy="strict-origin-when-cross-origin"></iframe>

### Barb Scherer

VP of Marketing, W.S. Badcock

How Setup saved time vetting agencies and provided an unbiased perspective on potential agency partners.

[Get Started with Custom Agency Search](https://share.hsforms.com/1PrIv865YQkCXArMBWmAa_Acpg62)

![Newell\_Brands\_logo.svg](https://info.setup.us/hs-fs/hubfs/Newell_Brands_logo.svg.png?width=2560&height=1230&name=Newell_Brands_logo.svg.png)

![IHG-Logo-2003](https://info.setup.us/hs-fs/hubfs/IHG-Logo-2003.png?width=5096&height=3206&name=IHG-Logo-2003.png)

![Red-Bull-Logo](https://info.setup.us/hs-fs/hubfs/Red-Bull-Logo.png?width=3840&height=2160&name=Red-Bull-Logo.png)

![Coca-Cola-logo\_480x480](https://info.setup.us/hs-fs/hubfs/Coca-Cola-logo_480x480.webp?width=480&height=270&name=Coca-Cola-logo_480x480.webp)

![Georgia-Pacific\_logo.svg](https://info.setup.us/hs-fs/hubfs/Georgia-Pacific_logo.svg.png?width=1200&height=218&name=Georgia-Pacific_logo.svg.png)

![Brooks Running Logo](https://info.setup.us/hs-fs/hubfs/Brooks%20Running%20Logo.webp?width=1180&height=540&name=Brooks%20Running%20Logo.webp)

## Tools & Insights for Agency Selection

### Agency Selection Scorecard

Compare RFI responses and finalist pitches using customizable criteria and weighted scoring.

[Open the scorecard](https://setup.us/agency-scorecard)

### 2025 Marketing Relationship Survey

Explore what brands and agencies say about delivery, value, and the factors that shape stronger working relationships.

[Read the 2025 results](https://setup.us/blog/2025-marketing-relationship-survey-results)

## Let's find the right agency partner for your brand.

Tell us about your goals, agency needs, and timing. We'll review your inquiry and follow up to discuss whether Custom Agency Search is the right fit.

[Get Started with Custom Agency Search](https://share.hsforms.com/1PrIv865YQkCXArMBWmAa_Acpg62)

© 2026 Setup, LLC

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "Service",
  "areaServed" : {
    "@type" : "Country",
    "name" : "United States"
  },
  "description" : "Setup’s Custom Agency Partner Search helps brands find the perfect marketing agency through a data-driven process.",
  "name" : "Custom Agency Partner Search",
  "provider" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "name" : "Setup",
    "url" : "https://setup.us"
  },
  "serviceType" : "Marketing Agency Matchmaking",
  "url" : "https://info.setup.us/custom-agency-partner-search"
}
```